951 Caroline Street, 305-296-4000 • Excellent steaks & seafood entrees, complimented by an outstanding wine list. Arguably the best steakhouse in the Keys, Prime Steakhouse is a white tablecloth, wood-paneled dining destination. Kitschy old Florida posters framed to conjure up the Art Deco heyday of the 1940s. From their house specialty bone-in ribeye to porterhouse to filet mignon or, better yet, the surf and turf, Prime Steakhouse delights discerning carnivores. The menu boasts all of your traditional steakhouse accompaniments: Caesar salad, filet mignon carpaccio and raw oysters, as well as pasta and fresh fish dishes.
- Best steakhouse in the Keys, without question.
Crowd: Sophisticated couples out for a special occasion and locals treating themselves.
What to Order: Pick your preferred cut of meat, but your order is not complete without a side of the truffle macaroni and smoked gouda cheese. While there’s an extensive wine list, you can’t go wrong by starting with a dirty martini with bleu cheese-stuffed olives.
951 Caroline Street, Key West, Florida 33040, United States of America